Tonight on LMN was the premiere (?) of a Melissa Joan Hart movie called Whispers and Lies. And, I mean, not that we wouldn’t have watched it anyway, but Sally and I dvr’ed it because it had something to do with a creepy, insular town whose residents were immortal, and we just can’t pass something like that up.
But, see, in the grand tradition of stranger-in-a-creepy-community-with-a-secret movies, this one’s secret made absolutely no sense. So, like, there’s The Spring with Kyle MacLaughlin, where he and his son are on a camping trip and he just sort of wanders into this little town and discovers that the water in the town is basically the fountain of youth and all the residents are immortal. But, the town wants to get him out of there because they don’t want the secret getting out. Of course, the son breaks his leg and the doctor decides to dip him into the lake to heal him, which kind of is how the secret got out, I think? So, why didn’t she just not do that? I don’t know. Anyway, but KMac gets REALLY hyper annoying and obsessive and decides that he wants to live there with all these people and he has to actually go to, like, a town council meeting and make his case (my wife died of cancer, boo hoo) and they actually approve him and and his son, but then his son realizes that there’s one other immortal teenager there and he’s kind of not the most fun kid in the world (because he’s really 100 years old, or something) and then he also realizes that being 14 forever will so be the pits, and KMac keeps telling him to back off because there’s a pretty doctor that he has to hit on. But, THEN, this guy that he becomes friends with is all, “It’s my birthday,” and KMac is all excited, but the guy seems all sad, and it turns out that on some birthday, you have to kill yourself in front of the whole town. Seriously! You have to stop drinking the fountain of youth water and die on your … 100th birthday? That doesn’t seem right. 100 years isn’t that long. But, I think it might be 100. I’m not sure. Anyway, so KMac hasn’t started drinking the water yet, but after he goes to the party (and he’s all excited like a doofus and then his friend is like, “Been nice knowing you,” and it still takes him about an hour to figure out what’s happening, like, did he never see the Lottery?) he realizes that killing yourself in front of the town WON’T be fun AND his dippy doctor gf is gonna have to kill herself in about a month and a half, so, tough luck. So, he runs away and he finds this one couple that decided to just stop drinking the water and NOT kill themselves and let nature take its course and they have the worst old-people makeup on ever. And this robo-cop guy chases him and he cries and begs and then they do some kind of thing where they make sure he never comes back to the town or something.
But, anyway, the reason they kill themselves and have a whole meeting about whether people can stay is that they don’t want the town to get overcrowded and become a tourist trap and let their springs dry up. So, that makes some amount of sense.
Then, speaking of the Lottery… That one has nothing to do with immortality, but, there is town killings and creepiness. Anyway, Dan Cortese’s dad dies and he wants to be buried in his old hometown with his wife, so DC goes there to carry out his father’s wishes, but they keep telling him it’s not possible because… he didn’t live there or something. Anyway, they won’t do it, but DC doesn’t get it AND he meets Jimmy James’s daughter Felicity and greases all over her and refuses to leave. But, see, the town is all idyllic (AND CREEPY! let’s just say overall it seemed to be a lot like that polygamist compound the police just raided a few days ago) and beautiful and DC is all, “I could live here forever!” despite the fact that every time he indicates that, everyone gets all shifty eyed. Anyway, he figures out (eventually) that the town wants to keep the population at a minimum because … their town is so great, or something? So, every year, they do a lottery, and the person whose name is drawn has to die. But, not just die! Be stoned to death! Like, what? So, after they blow up his car (literally!) and beat him up and stuff, they drag him in handcuffs to the lottery so he can see what he was disrupting by overstaying his (sweaty) welcome for too long, and then he watches Felicity’s mother’s name get drawn and Felicity TOTALLY STONE HER MOTHER TO DEATH! Like, teeth bared and everything. I saw this movie when it came out, because we were reading the short story in English class, like, that week, and I remember that scene every time I watch Felicity. But, anyway, then he remembers that his mother died in the lottery, and that, when she was calling out to him to help her, he totally stoned her, too. Creepy! But, anyway, so, crowd control? Population control? Anyway, the lottery, I guess, had some sort of purpose. A stupid one, but still.
Then, there’s The Glow, where these wacky old people living in a rent-controlled building in Manhattan (which is a bad sign! there are no rent-controlled apartments there that aren’t being used for nefarious reasons, trust me.) lure Portia DiRossi and Dean Cain into their weird scheme where they kill young, healthy, family-less couples and steal their “glow” and make it into milkshakes that they drink to become immortal. So, they’re just greedy old jerks who want to live forever.
Anyway, Whispers and Lies. I mean, Whispers and Lies? That title doesn’t have anything to do with the movie.
MJH’s cousin Patti met a guy on the “mainland” and recently started dating him. He lives on an island (I’m assuming off the coast of Washington or Oregon, since every Lifetime movie takes place in the Pacific Northwest) and Patti has been invited to visit him, but she brings MJH with her because she wants an opinion, and she’s nervous about going alone. So, they go for the week, and they stop off at this art show to meet the guy (Kyle). While they’re there, MJH starts looking at the (crappy) paintings and is approached by the artist, Chris. (Btw, the guy who played Chris was also in this movie called Cabin by the Lake with Judd Nelson. I’ve never seen it, but based on the imdb description, I think I might have to: “A screenwriter, who lives in a cabin by the lake near Los Angeles, drowns young women, then goes back to visit their bodies and do their laundry.” !!)
Anyway, Patti almost has her purse stolen and her arm gets cut in the process, and when she’s taken to the clinic, the doctor notices this birthmark on her shoulder and tells Patti that it’s actually an indication that she has an unusually strong immune system. Then, Patti goes missing all night and all the next day. When MJH wakes up and realizes she’s gone, she’s all worried, but everyone keeps telling her she’s probably just having a “good time with Kyle, wink wink” and MJH should lighten up. (That’s seriously what’s implied every single time.)
Meanwhile, MJH and Chris are hanging out and having awkwardly worded conversations, and then she gets a text from Patti saying that she’s fine, just got a little carried away and will be back soon. But, she signs her name “Patty” not “Patti” and MJH is just sort of like, “Huh, weird.” I mean, if my sister texted me and wrote her name “Salli”, I certainly wouldn’t think she was just typing fast. The i and the y are in totally different places! So annoying.
Anyway, MJH meets the girl who tried to mug Patti and it turns out she’s just a misunderstood goth teen whose foster mother is the town doctor. She also meets a crazy old man named Eugene who keeps following her and mumbling things about putting people inside of him, and then he grabs her so she’ll listen to him and then the sheriff shoots him and kills him. And then she talks to the doctor and reveals that she and Patti are cousins. Oh, and Chris makes out with her and notices her similar birthmark. And she finds out that Patti up and left without saying anything, and goes to question Kyle, and finds all of Patti’s belongings there, and Chris’s car horn keeps beeping uncontrollably, and then Kyle says that Patti left after an argument and forgot her stuff, and then Chris’s brakes go out and he makes MJH tuck and roll, and then he gets thrown from the car and has to go to the clinic. Then MJH tells the doctor to take him to the mainland and she’s all, “We take care of our own,” but, like, an hour later she gets shifty-eyed and says she took her advice and he’s gone. THEN, MJH sees the teen and follows her to a cemetery and notices that there are no dates on the markers and finds out that there was an epidemic and everyone started dying and then the doctor found a cure, and that all the teen wants to do is run away and live a normal life, and MJH says she’ll help her because she’s a hs science teacher, and teachers don’t break promises, and I laughed and laughed. Oh, and then the teen tells her where Eugene’s house was so that she could nose around, and she finds an old-timey portrait of Eugene and his family, and she takes it with her, and then, when she’s driving back to the hotel, she’s pulled over and the cop tells her that they found Patti and she’s dead. And MJH has to identify the body, and they tell her that Patti drowned (but she was a lifeguard!) and THEN they say that she was seen drinking (but she doesn’t drink!) and that she must have fallen, hit her head, and landed in the water. And the doctor insists on doing an autopsy before MJH can have the body, and MJH is all no way jose, but the doctor’s all I’m a coroner so what? and MJH has to be all fine, whatever, and then the doctor gives her pills to sleep and sends her home.
So… That all happened in one day. That whole paragraph up there! I feel like Richie Tankersley Cusick wrote this screenplay.
The next day, MJH goes to the library and looks at old newspapers and discovers a whole heap of tourist deaths, and that a newspaper from 1862 shows the portrait of Eugene and his family that she saw at his house. And she takes the picture out of her purse and holds it to the screen and looks back and forth a few times. But, like, it’s a really big picture, and it’s not that hard to tell that it’s the same exact photo.
And she’s told by some surly fishermen that her cousin drowned and THAT’S THAT, MISS, and then she hears Chris’s signature hacking and wheezing and sees him driving off with Kyle, and she goes to the doctor’s office to ask what’s up and notices the whole town in line for “flu shots.” And then she gets that teen girl to help her break into the doctor’s office that night and discovers that Patti’s body has been completely drained of blood and that the autopsy report for Patti and every other tourist who’s died includes a picture of their giant birthmarks and MJH is next!
So, she goes to find Chris and he’s, like, totally fine even after the horrific car accident he was in, and he tells her that he’ll explain what’s going on after he gets her to his private dingy and sails her to the mainland, but MJH is arrested, like, the second they walk out the door, and Chris is held back from helping her and told that he’s become a liability, and I honestly don’t know what they do with him or why they don’t bring him to jail. But, anyway, in the jail, MJH does this whole sassy, “What excuse are you gonna use for MY death, huh?” routine, but then, practically as you’re still hearing her talking, they cut to a scene of her crying with her hands over her face. It was weird. Very RTC. Oh! Eugene is alive! And in the jail cell next to her! And the teen has the keys to the jail cells (?) and lets MJH out and she and Chris and the teen go running through the woods and try to escape but don’t. MJH then screeches to the townspeople that she’s noticed they’re all not so immortal anymore, and ARE becoming susceptible to illnesses and the doctor has been acting shady and not letting them in on this secret (?) and they very very quickly turn on the doctor and let MJH and Chris and the teen go, the end.
So, it turns out that super immunity thing that MJH and Patti and the other dead tourists have is something that has been harvested and injected into the townspeople for the last 150-odd years to keep them healthy and make them heal really fast after injuries. So, they had this epidemic and, according to the doctor, the whole world abandoned them and they were on their own to find a cure. So, she found one and used it, and all these people were okay.
But, then… I don’t know how this stuff ended up making them stop aging. But, for whatever reason, it did. What makes NO sense is the fact that they all continued to use it to BECOME immortal. Because, honestly? They all seem miserable! Half of the people in the town seem to be in their late 70s and older, which had to have been very old for the time when they first became immortal, right? So, why did they even want to become immortal at that age? They’re still all old creakers, so it didn’t seem to make them more spry, like the Glow. And they all kind of seem like they WANT to die, despite their protestations. I mean, everyone seems really sad there, so I don’t get why they were immortal. I could see if they all had some kind of disease that meant they had to keep sacrificing innocent people to survive, but they don’t seem to be afflicted with this illness anymore, so why do they have to keep up with the injections? AND, why wouldn’t they just let that teen girl go when she wanted to? If she stops taking the injections, she’ll age like a normal person. And she just wants to leave the island and age and then die one day like everyone else. So, if she leaves, then there’ll be more blood for the rest of them on the next go-round for injections. What is the advantage to keeping her there? She wouldn’t help any of them live more, and she clearly didn’t want to let anyone know about the island.
I mean, all I’m saying is, that if you’re going to do the whole creepy townspeople thing, it should be harder to get away in the end. Like, you should have to blow them up, or something. Not just say, “Live your lives, the best you can. It’s what everyone else has to do…” and watch them nod their heads and just wander away! And, if you’re gonna do immorality… It should either be something beyond their control, like, something they HAVE to do, or something that they’re greedy for.
But, what can I say? Not everything can handle immortality like New Amsterdam. The fact that this guy is this guy’s son? Never gets old. Ever.














